Old vines: plenty of history, no automatic guarantee of quality
19 November 2026 · sommelier.vi.cat
A twisted vine has an extraordinary ability to sell a story before the bottle is opened. That does not make the story false; neither does it turn it into a tasting. The myth worth examining is the automatic jump from “old vines” to “better wine”. Age can be valuable information. An absolute guarantee is something else.
First, establish which age is being described
Resolution OIV-VITI 703-2024 defines an old grapevine as at least 35 documented years old; for grafted plants, that union must have remained intact for at least that period. In an old vineyard, at least 85% of plants must qualify. These are identification criteria, not a sensory score.
When reading a label, we suggest asking what is described: a plant, a plot or the origin of all the grapes in the wine. These units are not interchangeable. A planting date can be relevant without settling a bottle’s composition. Nor should an international definition become a blanket statement about every country’s labelling rules.
The library requires historical context
In the Spanish edition of Hugh Johnson and Jancis Robinson’s World Atlas of Wine consulted in our library, page 46 explains vieilles vignes with a qualification: greater density is presented as theoretical. We checked the original page. It provides useful historical context, but cannot replace the later 2024 definition.
That distinction matters in wine writing. A book can remain valuable while describing the regulatory circumstances of its own time. Reading it alongside a current source preserves knowledge without freezing the calendar. The library loses no authority by requiring context; we would lose some by failing to provide it.
What one experiment found, and what it cannot prove
A study by Bou Nader and colleagues, published in OENO One on 15 October 2026, compared Riesling vines of different ages in Rheingau during the 2015–2017 harvests. Mature and old vines showed similar composition for most compounds studied. The work analysed grape components: it was not a universal wine competition and does not prove young vines always make better wine.
Its relevance lies in the question it allows us to ask. If two groups do not differ clearly on a measurement, we cannot invent an advantage simply because one is older. Equally, a particular measurement cannot encompass everything meant by quality. The conclusion should remain attached to its variety, location, seasons and variables, rather than being expanded to every vineyard on earth.
Three separate questions improve the conversation
The first question is documentary: which age is substantiated? The second is agronomic: what is known about these plants’ performance in their location? The third is sensory: how has the wine been assessed? Our suggestion is not to answer all three with one adjective. “Old” may answer part of the first; the others require evidence of their own.
Preference and superiority should also be distinguished. Enjoying a particular wine more does not establish a causal rule about all vines of that age. And an unexciting bottle does not cancel its vineyard’s historical interest. Either shortcut makes the conversation faster, but less precise.
Conservation need not promise perfection
We can care about an old planting, its continuity and the work maintaining it without promising that it will win every tasting. That is our editorial conclusion: explaining heritage well is more convincing than granting it automatic powers. A vine’s birthday deserves attention; it need not decide for us what is in the glass.
Sources. World Atlas of Wine, Johnson and Robinson, Spanish edition, original p. 46 consulted in the private library; OIV-VITI 703-2024; Bou Nader et al., OENO One 60(4), DOI 10.20870/oeno-one.2026.60.4.10222. Accessed 19 November 2026. No scans or private links are reproduced. By sommelier.vi.cat.
